Just throwing my .02 I really enjoy the Index controllers (huge step up from HTC wands) this clicking on the thumbstick is really nothing to my main complaint. My issue is the actual LOCATION of the thumb stick.. it needs to be switched with Valves silly useless touch pads. It would feel soo much more natural if they were in the (imo) proper spot.
For one thing the Touch controllers are much lighter.
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!